Holy City

Several versions of this recording exist on Edison #2018: Version 1: an 1897 version recorded by [a847630] and released on a brown wax cylinder Version 2: Harry Macdonough also recorded versions in 1898 for release on both brown wax and Edison concert cylinders; these versions have a piano accompaniment Version 3: Macdonough remade this selection with an organ accompaniment in 1902 for release on the new Gold Moulded cylinders Version 4: Macdonough remade this again after 1902, accompanied by an orchestra Version 5: [a409830] (as "[a3459263]") also recorded this song and his version was released on Edison cylinders with this catalog number It is unclear whether this release represents version 3 or 4. Since this entry has the title, etc, in bold white at the end of the cylinder, it is likely to be a repress from 1904 or later.